The Renaissance and the End of the Middle Ages

 I've been focusing a lot on science and science fiction stuff, without enough talk about the past (the "swords" of "Swords and Space") so I thought it high time to do a post with the history tag. In discussing the HBO rendition of A Song of Rape and Murder, the Renaissance came up in the comments box and I think the point is worth emphasizing a bit more.

Unfortunately, I think a lot of people conflate the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, especially when it comes to negatives. The Middle Ages therefore gets tarred with the crimes of Renaissance, and somehow the Renaissance tends to get a free pass. For example, the favourite slander that Medieval people had poor hygiene actually comes during the Renaissance and the so-called "Enlightenment". There are many more crimes that belong solely to the Renaissance and have nothing to do with the Middle Ages, but I won't be able to get into all of those today. The important thing to keep in mind is that the Middle Ages was the culmination of centuries of the Catholic faith being integrated into society, and the Renaissance was a conscious return to paganism (they may not have started publicly worshiping Jupiter, but they did return to pagan principles).

So G.R.R. Martin apparently used material on The War of the Roses as his "inspiration" for the civil war in his books. Worth noting is that the War of the Roses began in 1455. Without getting into how his depiction of such a war is outrageously ridiculous even in the Renaissance, I note that we're well into that pagan period at 1455. Many historians give the fall of Constantinople as the end of the Middle ages in 1453. I myself prefer the reasoning of Atila Sinke Guimarães, who puts the end of the Middle Ages (or, at the very least, the beginning of the end) was 8 September 1303 a.D.

That day, in the town of Anagni, about forty miles south of Rome, William of Nogaret, councillor and keeper of the seal to King Philip IV of France abducted Pope Boniface VIII. Nogaret had been sent to Italy with the task of kidnapping the Pope and bringing him to France for a show trial to be followed by deposition. Nogaret gathered together a band of some 1,600 rogues and political enemies of the Gaetani family (Boniface VIII's family) and suddenly attacked the town, looted the castle, and took the pope captive. After two days of humiliation and threats, the people of Anagni rose up and expelled Nogaret and his men. The pope died in Rome a month later, however.

This event is significant because it was a terrible blow against supremacy of the Papacy over the temporal monarchs, which was one of the great characteristics of the Middle Ages. That supremacy was important for many reasons, but thinking back again to the discussion of A Game of Thrones, in the real world when nobles behaved even half as badly as Martin's nobles, they would be excommunicated (if they didn't meet another bad end). The role of the Church in the Middle Ages did a great deal to rein-in those few lords who might abuse their powers -- contrasted with the Renaissance where the Church was less powerful (especially after the Protestant Revolt).

No comments:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...